Kingsview Wealth Blog

Ask Tim: A Day Trader’s Worst Nightmare

Written by Kingsview Wealth | Apr 8, 2026 2:16:31 PM

It’s Master’s Week, which means I’m spending the next four days lounging on the couch drinking Azaleas, chowing down pimento cheese sandwiches, and ignoring all responsibilities my wife throws at me.

My pick to win this week: Rory McIlroy.

He’s been playing some rather average tour golf this year, but I think he’s destined to break out and be in form this week. He’s one of the greatest of this generation (if not ever) — he’s going to pull off back-to-back wins in Augusta.

Back to what’s really important — your questions.

This week, we’re covering a day trader’s tax bill surprise and wary investing as the war in the Middle East heats up (or maybe it’s cooling down? Who knows at this point).

Anyway, let’s get the ball rolling (pun intended).

I picked up day trading last year. Now, my tax bill is bigger than my profits. How is that possible?

Dear Tim,

I am 29, live in Charlotte, and last year I got a little too comfortable after a few early wins in the market. What started as a side hobby turned into a daily routine. By midyear, I was in and out of positions constantly, chasing momentum, taking quick gains, and telling myself I had a feel for it. Then the year turned, the statements showed up, and suddenly the tax side looked a whole lot uglier than the brokerage app ever did.

What really threw me was this: I do not feel like I made some huge pile of money. In fact, after a rough stretch late in the year, my account felt pretty ordinary. Yet my tax bill looks like I struck gold and forgot to share with the IRS. I keep hearing phrases like wash sale, short-term gain, and capital loss carryforward, and every one of them sounds like something designed in a lab to ruin a good mood. I am trying to figure out how a guy can end a year feeling barely ahead and still owe a meaningful check.

Part of what makes this sting is how fast it happened. A few lucky trades turned into a lot of confidence, and a lot of confidence turned into a lot of clicks. I thought the hard part was picking winners. Turns out the hard part may be keeping enough aside for taxes and realizing that a pile of short-term gains, plus losses you cannot fully use right away, can create a nasty surprise. I am all for learning a lesson, though I would prefer one that costs less.

- Burned by the Blinkers

Dear Burned by the Blinkers,

Here is the heart of it: the tax code tracks each sale, while your brain usually tracks the final account balance. Those are very different scoreboards. Frequent trading often creates a stack of short-term gains taxed at ordinary income rates, while wash-sale rules can delay part of your loss deduction, and net capital losses above $3,000 usually carry forward rather than helping much this year.

A few variables swing the answer. First is the holding period. Positions held a year or less usually land in short-term gain territory, which generally means higher tax rates than long-term gains. Second is the wash-sale activity. If you sold at a loss and bought a substantially identical security within the 30-day window, that loss can get deferred into the replacement position rather than helping your current return. Third is sheer volume. A lot of small wins and losses can still leave a bigger tax bill than your gut expected.

A simple example makes this easier. Say you booked $40,000 of short-term gains early in the year, then later took $35,000 of losses. On paper, you may feel like you came out roughly $5,000 ahead. Yet if $20,000 of those losses got pushed aside by wash-sale rules, your current-year taxable gain could still look closer to $25,000. At a combined federal and state rate in the low 30s, that can sting fast. Welcome to the least fun math class in America.

This week, I would pull your realized gain and loss report, isolate every wash-sale adjustment, and ask a CPA or enrolled agent to map what hit 2025 versus what rolled forward. I would also build a habit for 2026: set aside tax cash as gains are realized, and ease up on rapid re-entry into the same names after a loss sale. Fast fingers and tax forms rarely become close friends.

A lot of people miss one thing here: profit in the account and taxable income on the return are cousins, yet they are rarely twins. Add wash sales, year-end open positions, and short-term treatment, and April can feel like a magic trick performed by an unfriendly accountant. The fix usually starts with better tracking and a more deliberate trading process.

My view: this is possible, it is common, and it is fixable. The lesson is expensive, though it can still pay off if it changes how you trade from here on out.

With chaos in the Middle East, I have grown wary of the market. As a planner, where would you place my assets until things calm down?

Dear Tim,

I am 42, live in Florida, and sold my contracting business last year. After years of busting my tail, I finally have real liquidity sitting there, and that should feel great. Instead, it feels like a strange mix of relief and paralysis. The headlines feel heavy, markets feel twitchy, and every time I think about putting the money to work, I picture myself making a move at exactly the wrong time. Right now, a big chunk is just sitting in the bank, which feels safe, though it also feels lazy.

I have looked at money markets and short-term cash options, though I keep thinking there has to be a smarter middle ground between letting it idle and tossing it into a market that feels jumpy by the hour. I am after yield, sure, though I am also after sleep. I do not need heroics. I need a place for this capital where I can preserve flexibility, pick up a fair return, and keep myself from doing something rash just because the world feels loud.

There is also a tax angle here that I am trying to think through more carefully this year. Last year came with the business sale, and this year feels like the first time in a long time that I can step back and actually build a plan instead of just reacting. So when I ask where the money should go “for now,” I really mean what makes sense for someone who wants optionality, reasonable income, and a path back into longer-term investing without making every choice from a place of nerves.

- Parked in the Driveway

Dear Parked in the Driveway,

Congratulations on selling your business and entering this next chapter in your financial journey.

First, I would separate this decision from the headlines. Selling a business and transitioning into this next chapter creates a financial planning event. The combination of being flooded with liquidity, navigating the tax consequences, and having the rare flexibility to completely rehaul your financial picture to fit your future needs is often an overwhelming experience. Add in the constant uncertainty highlighted on the news, and it is easy to feel stuck.

There is a lot going on right now with your personal situation and around the world. It is important to separate what you can control today from what you cannot. Build around the controllable variables and stay grounded with respect to the things beyond your influence.

When someone says, “Where should I put it until things calm down,” many professionals jump straight to a favorite trade or portfolio without digging for context. Hearing your story and the circumstances around it, the real question is likely closer to this: How do I isolate myself from the chaos in the world while putting myself in the best position for my future?

Let us assume the following case facts:

42 years old, retired
$500,000 Traditional IRA (rolled from a former company 401(k))
$250,000 taxable investment account
$2 million cash in the bank (net proceeds from the sale of the company)

Having that liquidity on hand gives you great flexibility in how you structure your financial picture today and moving forward.

When it comes to isolating risk, the geopolitical events playing out today will continue to affect the markets. To be frank, the current Iran situation will pass, and then the next story will take its place in swaying investor sentiment. So let us build a foundation that limits market volatility and its effect on your future, so that as the noise changes, your approach does not.

When it comes to limiting risk, we often think of cash, CDs, high-quality bonds, and annuity products issued by strong carriers as safer vehicles compared with equities.

Learning how to effectively complement these instruments with traditional equity investments participating in the broader market is the sweet spot to aim for. This mix typically varies based on each client’s unique needs and considerations.

Back to our case facts above. Let us assume that after extensive discussions about what we are solving for, we arrive at the following approach to address your short-, intermediate-, and long-term needs.

Short-Term Focus ($400,000)

Setting aside funds for the next 1–2 years is important for easing concerns about access to liquidity while also generating some yield on idle funds. Within this bucket, the primary focus is liquidity and maintaining stable value. This bucket would likely be a mix of cash, money market funds, and a short-term Treasury ladder.

Cash and money market funds would remain accessible for everyday expenses and unforeseen needs.

A short-term Treasury ladder could generate some yield with frequent maturity dates that help refill the cash bucket or be reinvested as needed.

Intermediate-Term Focus ($600,000)

These funds are set aside for the coming 3–7 years, gradually topping off the short-term bucket over time. Within this second bucket, the primary focus would be generating yield or stable growth to complement the third bucket, likely through a mix of CDs and an intermediate-term bond ladder.

CDs, whether traditional or structured, can offer competitive yield with lock-up periods and performance triggers where applicable.
An intermediate-term bond ladder, whether Treasury or municipal, can offer advantages depending on the broader outlook.

Both can provide flexibility to either use or reinvest the income accordingly.

Long-Term Focus ($1,750,000)

These funds are set aside for everything beyond the intermediate-term need. In your 40s, this could include distant goals like retirement lifestyle or legacy desires. Within this third bucket, the primary focus is often growth and income. The mix generally leans more heavily into equity investments in the broader market and complementary insurance contracts.

Equity investments open up a much wider range of possibilities here across market caps, styles, and sectors. The goal is to participate in long-term market growth while tactfully limiting risk.
Insurance contracts, whether life insurance, long-term care, or annuities, can help offset risks tied to mortality, health, or longevity.

To recap, this could create a financial foundation that resembles a traditional portfolio, combining all three buckets, of $2.25 million with an overall allocation of 55% equity and 45% fixed income.

You may have noticed that this total is $500,000 short of the $2.75 million portfolio total as it stands today.

That is because we are complementing the traditional portfolio with a $500,000 fixed indexed annuity, funded by a rollover from the Traditional IRA.

The FIA participates in the growth of an underlying index with a year-over-year performance range of 0% to 8%, with the performance floor reset annually after prior-year interest is credited. This strategy also eventually turns into a guaranteed income stream based on the greater of the benefit base or the accumulated value within the contract.

By combining annuity income with Social Security, this sample client can lessen the distribution burden on the portfolio in later years, helping offset the risk of outliving savings.

To mitigate timing risk during implementation, the roughly $2 million of cash currently being held could be dollar-cost averaged into the portfolio. That means for the more volatile investments, a fixed portion of the end-target allocation would be invested into the market periodically regardless of market conditions. This helps spread out the entry point and reduce the risk of poor timing.

If you would like a second set of eyes on your financial situation, working with a quality wealth manager can be a game-changer in setting everything up around your needs and helping coach you through the tribulations of the news cycle.

If you are set on navigating this road alone, your next step this week is to map the cash into time buckets before chasing yield. Figure out what must stay liquid for expenses or residual taxes, what may be needed for life and opportunity, and what truly belongs to long-range planning.

Then compare bank yields, Treasury ladders, and high-quality short-duration options through that lens. “More than money markets” sounds appealing, though a small yield pickup can come with price movement, credit risk, or both.

Regardless, the easy miss here is taxes on idle cash and the silent cost of delay. Potential interest, bond income, and market growth can each carry their own planning implications. Spending a year on the sideline in fear can create significant lost potential due to compounding, or worse, inaction becomes the action and the funds never make it into the strategies needed to fund your future.

Also, if a large tax payment from the business sale is still looming, preserve that cash first. The IRS remains very interested in estimated taxes, even when the market feels dramatic.

My view: start with buckets and build a foundation that creates intentional direction rather than reactive corrections. Calm usually arrives after structure, rather than before it.