The question of whether to convert a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA has always invited debate. It depends on tax rates, market conditions, and personal circumstances. But in 2025, the decision carries added weight, because the current tax code is scheduled to change in 2026 when provisions from the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act are set to expire.
Why the Question Matters Now
For the past several years, individuals have benefitted from historically low federal income tax brackets. These lower rates are temporary. If Congress does nothing, the brackets will reset in 2026 to higher, pre-2017 levels. This looming change makes 2025 a pivotal year to consider whether to convert part of a retirement account to Roth status.
Converting to a Roth requires paying ordinary income taxes on the amount shifted. That upfront cost is often the biggest sticking point. Yet the long-term benefit can be substantial: withdrawals in retirement are tax-free, provided you meet IRS rules. For many savers, the trade-off boils down to whether they prefer paying taxes at today’s lower rate or facing potentially higher taxes down the line.
Who Stands to Benefit
Roth conversions are rarely one-size-fits-all. They tend to favor individuals who:
- Expect to be in the same or higher tax bracket later in life
- Can cover the conversion tax bill with non-retirement funds
- Have a long time horizon before needing withdrawals
- Want to leave tax-free assets to heirs
On the other hand, those nearing retirement or those who need to keep taxable income low — for Medicare premium thresholds or Social Security tax considerations — may find conversions less appealing. Timing, age, and cash-flow flexibility all matter in determining whether a conversion makes sense.
Strategic Considerations for 2025
A full conversion isn’t the only option. Many advisors recommend partial conversions, spread over several years, to help smooth out the tax impact while still locking in today’s lower rates. Pairing a conversion with charitable giving can also offset taxable income and improve the after-tax result.
Market conditions can influence strategy as well. Converting during periods of volatility — especially if your account value has temporarily declined—may reduce the tax cost. When the market eventually rebounds, the recovery occurs inside the Roth, free of future taxation. Investors who lived through the downturns of 2000 or 2008 know just how powerful well-timed tax planning can be.
Additional Factors to Keep in Mind
- Five-Year Rule: Withdrawals of earnings from a Roth are only tax-free if at least five years have passed since the first conversion (and you’re over age 59½).
- Impact on Benefits: A conversion increases your taxable income for the year, which can affect Medicare premiums and the portion of Social Security subject to tax.
- State Taxes: Not all states treat Roth conversions the same way. Consider your state’s rules when weighing the tax cost.
- Estate Planning: Passing Roth assets to heirs can provide them with years of tax-free growth, especially under current 10-year distribution rules for inherited accounts.
Looking Ahead
For many households, 2025 may represent the last clear opportunity to convert before tax brackets rise. Others may decide the upfront cost outweighs the future benefits. The best path forward depends on personal circumstances, income levels, and long-term goals.
The wisest approach is to run the numbers carefully — or better yet, work with a qualified advisor — to evaluate whether a Roth conversion aligns with your overall retirement strategy.
.png?width=48&height=48&name=KVP-background1%20(2).png){kind=small}
